Why is Windows XP so insecure these days?

In the annals of computer history, there are few operating systems that have achieved the iconic status of Windows XP. Released in 2001 as the successor to Windows ME and Windows 2000, it quickly became a popular standard in homes and businesses around the world. However, despite its fondly remembered interface and groundbreaking features for its time, Windows XP is woefully insecure today. For those of us who follow operating system development closely, understanding why XP has become a digital relic is both fascinating and important.

If you want to install Windows XP, you can actually still do that these days and try it out on a virtual machine. However, we don't recommend this as it's more like stepping into a digital museum than a usable operating system these days. There are still many programs that only run on Windows XP, which is why hospitals and older companies still have systems that use this operating system.

Windows XP is completely outdated

No more updates or changes will be received

The first nail in the coffin of Windows XP security was April 8, 2014. On that day, Microsoft officially ended mainstream support for the operating system. In other words, that meant no more security updates, no more patches of any kind, and no more technical support from Microsoft. Without these important updates, any vulnerabilities discovered after that date will remain unpatched.

That's why there are unofficial patches and changes you can make to Windows XP. Also, Microsoft released an unprecedented update after WannaCry and another bug before it was exploited in the wild. Essentially, though, Windows XP just doesn't receive updates anymore, making it even less likely that any exploits found will be patched and fixed.

A product of a bygone era

Windows XP is based on completely different security paradigms than modern security systems.

Windows XP was developed in a very different era. The operating system's architecture reflects the security paradigms of the late 1990s and early 2000s. Since then, the field of cybersecurity has evolved and changed in leaps and bounds. Modern operating systems have features such as advanced memory protection, secure boot, and sophisticated encryption protocols – all areas in which XP is sorely lacking.

Windows XP simply lacks a lot of security features that make newer versions of Windows more secure. In fact, Windows 11 already has some new features that theoretically make the system more secure than Windows 10, and we're talking about 20 years of changes between Windows 11 and Windows XP.

For example, most operating systems use techniques such as Address Space Layout Randomization (ASLR) and Data Execution Prevention (DEP) to protect against memory-based attacks. ASLR randomizes the memory addresses used by system and application processes, making it harder for attackers to predict where their malicious code will run. DEP, on the other hand, prevents code from executing in memory areas intended for storing data, thwarting attempts to exploit vulnerabilities. Windows XP never had ASLR, and DEP was only added in SP2.

To go a step further, features like Secure Boot, added with Windows 8 in 2011, ensure that only trusted software that has been verified by the system's firmware is allowed to run during the boot process. This is also noticeably missing from Windows XP.

Compatibility issues with newer software versions

Users are forced to use older software versions

One of the biggest problems with Windows XP is its incompatibility with most standard security solutions. Modern antivirus and anti-malware programs are designed for the latest operating systems, have advanced detection algorithms and real-time scanning, and use operating system features that are only available in newer versions.

However, because Windows XP lacks the necessary infrastructure, support, and APIs, many of these cutting-edge security tools are no longer compatible. Users still using XP are forced to rely on outdated security software that does not provide effective protection against new types of malware and exploits, leaving their systems extremely vulnerable. In addition, they often have to use older versions of popular applications to even run them. This may force them to use older programs that are also vulnerable to attacks.

Windows XP is incredibly insecure, and that's not the only problem with it

The only way to ensure safety is air gapping.

Even without the security risks of Windows XP, it simply gets harder to use over time. Devices that require proprietary drivers won't work on older operating systems like XP, and the security risks that arise when older software requires older operating systems are not to be underestimated.

For example, when the NHS was hacked thanks to WannaCry, many of the machines were still running Windows XP. But that wasn't the whole story; many MRI machines and other devices have partner software that only runs on Windows XP and has never been updated or requires significantly more changes than just an operating system upgrade. It's a perfect storm that can only be mitigated by completely isolating these machines, meaning they are not connected to a network.

That Windows XP is insecure is obvious, but the reasons for it are the most interesting. There is not just one reason that makes this statement true, but a whole series of reasons. There are also obviously the reasons why it is necessary to run it that we have laid out. So don't immediately shy away from the presence of Windows XP on a computer; ask yourself why it is there in the first place.

Related

Windows 11 2024 Update: What's new and why it's not Windows 12

The Windows 11 2024 update will bring a lot of changes to the operating system, including better support for Arm devices.